Another “documented” case! American Arbitration Association, Commercial Arbitration Tribunal, orders Chesapeake to pay Jacqueline Place of Terry Township, Bradford County PA, $60,000 for temporary methane contamination in water well after hydraulic fracturing

Woman wins case against Chesapeake Jacqueline Place of Terry Township to receive compensation for well contamination by Brendan Gibbons, Times-Shamrock, February 19, 2014, The Daily Review
An arbitrator ordered Chesapeake Appalachia LLC pay a Bradford County woman nearly $60,000 for contaminating her water well with methane. Jacqueline Place signed a lease in June 2008 that included an arbitration clause specifying American Arbitration Association as the forum for resolution of any claims resulting from damages caused by the Chesapeake’s operations.

In December 2008, Place hired a consultant to conduct baseline tests of the water from her well, according to legal documents provided by her attorney, John Barry Beemer. That test showed the well had methane levels of 0.01 parts per million. The baseline test became the foundation of her arbitration case, Beemer said. “If you don’t have that baseline testing, you don’t have a case, basically,” he said.

In August 2009, Chesapeake finished drilling a well, Barrett 2H in Asylum Twp., underneath Place’s property to extract gas from her land. The bottom of that well’s bore is within 80 yards of Place’s water well, according to Place’s arbitration brief. On March 22, 2010, Place noticed her water had become “reddish brown” and “oily.” She told Chesapeake and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. Both came to test her water that April.

Both found dissolved methane levels 1,300 to 2,000 times higher than the baseline tests, the brief states.

The DEP determined the well water should not be used. Chesapeake brought in at least one water buffalo as a temporary water supply and installed methane monitoring equipment.

Chesapeake, the DEP and Place’s consultant continued to test the well over the next several months, finding “levels of methane hundreds of times higher than the pre-drilling ‘baseline’ results from 2008, as well as increased iron and turbidity.”

In December 2010, the DEP gave Chesapeake permission to reconnect Place’s well, which the company did in January 2011. In February 2011, the department issued a Section 208 determination letter saying Chesapeake’s operations caused a “temporary impact” to the well and recommended ongoing testing.

The DEP, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and Place’s consultant continued testing the well over the following 16 months, finding methane at levels higher than the baseline but below the DEP’s action level.

In May 2013, a trial expert Place hired found a methane level of 0.042 parts per million. Place and her son still drink bottled water, the brief states.

“In short, Jacqueline Place lived for ten months deprived totally of the use of her well, and even after its ‘restoration,’ has been burdened with a water supply with chronic contamination, requiring constant vigilance and ongoing monitoring, according to the brief.

Beemer and his co-counsel, Gerald Williams of Philadelphia, represented Place in an arbitration hearing at Beemer’s law office in Clarks Green that lasted from Jan. 6 through Jan. 8.

Ross F. Schmucki, the arbitrator for American Arbitration Association, ordered Chesapeake to pay $59,381.42. [Emphasis added]

Bradford County woman wins arbitration case with Chesapeake over well contamination by Bendand Gibbons, February 19, 2014, The Times Tribune

2014 01 22 Arbitration Award JT Place & Chesapeake 60,000 less half costs

2014 01 22 Arbitration Award JT Place a win against Chesapeake for contaminating her ww w methane after fracing pretest essentially a negative result

Snaps above from the Arbitrator’s Decision

Read the award

2011 American Arbitration Association Recovery of legal fees and costs in Arbitration, not necessarily a given

Snap above from American Arbitration Association’s Recovery of Legal Fees and Costs in Arbitration: The What, When, Where, Why and How Webinar Recorded October 19, 2011

[Refer also to:

2013 Jessica Ernst trying to load water tank at Rosebud

2013: Jessica trying to load her water tank. Hard and heavy work for one person. Encana frac’d the Rosebud drinking aquifers in March 2004. Jessica still lives without safe water.

2013 06 Criminalize fracing Encana 7-13 compressors at Rosebud Alberta

This entry was posted in Global Frac News, Other Lawsuits. Bookmark the permalink.