Originally posted March 3, 2019; Reposted July 10, 2019
Radar satellite images show a large swath of Texas oil patch is heaving and sinking at alarming rates, according to a geophysical team. Analysis of the images with oil activity data from the Texas Railroad Commission suggests decades of oil activity have destabilized localities of the 4,000-square-mile area, which is populated by small towns, roadways and a vast network of oil and gas pipelines and storage tanks.
Two giant sinkholes near Wink, Texas, may just be the tip of the iceberg, according to a new study that found alarming rates of new ground movement extending far beyond the infamous sinkholes.
That’s the finding of a geophysical team from Southern Methodist University, Dallas that previously reported the rapid rate at which the sinkholes are expanding and new ones forming.
Now the team has discovered that various locations in large portions of four Texas counties are also sinking and uplifting.
Radar satellite images show significant movement of the ground across a 4000-square-mile area — in one place as much as 40 inches over the past two-and-a-half years, say the geophysicists.
“The ground movement we’re seeing is not normal. The ground doesn’t typically do this without some cause,” said geophysicist Zhong Lu, a professor in the Roy M. Huffington Department of Earth Sciences at SMU and a global expert in satellite radar imagery analysis.
“These hazards represent a danger to residents, roads, railroads, levees, dams, and oil and gas pipelines, as well as potential pollution of ground water,” Lu said. “Proactive, continuous detailed monitoring from space is critical to secure the safety of people and property.”
The scientists made the discovery with analysis of medium-resolution (15 feet to 65 feet) radar imagery taken between November 2014 and April 2017. The images cover portions of four oil-patch counties where there’s heavy production of hydrocarbons from the oil-rich West Texas Permian Basin.
The imagery, coupled with oil-well production data from the Texas Railroad Commission, suggests the area’s unstable ground is associated with decades of oil activity and its effect on rocks below the surface of the earth.
The SMU researchers caution that ground movement may extend beyond what radar observed in the four-county area. The entire region is highly vulnerable to human activity due to its geology — water-soluble salt and limestone formations, and shale formations.
“Our analysis looked at just this 4000-square-mile area,” said study co-author and research scientist Jin-Woo Kim, a research scientist in the SMU Department of Earth Sciences.
“We’re fairly certain that when we look further, and we are, that we’ll find there’s ground movement even beyond that,” Kim said.
“This region of Texas has been punctured like a pin cushion with oil wells and injection wells since the 1940s and our findings associate that activity with ground movement.” [Like Alberta]
Lu, Shuler-Foscue Chair at SMU, and Kim reported their findings in the Nature publication Scientific Reports, in the article “Association between localized geohazards in West Texas and human activities, recognized by Sentinel-1A/B satellite radar imagery.”
The researchers analyzed satellite radar images that were made public by the European Space Agency, and supplemented that with oil activity data from the Texas Railroad Commission.
The study is among the first of its kind to identify small-scale deformation signals over a vast region by drawing from big data sets spanning a number of years and then adding supplementary information.
The research is supported by the NASA Earth Surface and Interior Program, and the Shuler-Foscue Endowment at SMU.
Imagery captures changes that might otherwise go undetected
The SMU geophysicists focused their analysis on small, localized, rapidly developing hazardous ground movements in portions of Winkler, Ward, Reeves and Pecos counties, an area nearly the size of Connecticut. The study area includes the towns of Pecos, Monahans, Fort Stockton, Imperial, Wink and Kermit.
The images from the European Space Agency are the result of satellite radar interferometry from recently launched open-source orbiting satellites that make radar images freely available to the public.
With interferometric synthetic aperture radar, or InSAR for short, the satellites allow scientists to detect changes that aren’t visible to the naked eye and that might otherwise go undetected.
The satellite technology can capture ground deformation with an accuracy of sub-inches or better, at a spatial resolution of a few yards or better over thousands of miles, say the researchers.
Ground movement associated with oil activity
The SMU researchers found a significant relationship between ground movement and oil activities that include pressurized fluid injection into the region’s geologically unstable rock formations.
Fluid injection includes waste saltwater injection into nearby wells, and carbon dioxide flooding of depleting reservoirs to stimulate oil recovery.
Injected fluids increase the pore pressure in the rocks, and the release of the stress is followed by ground uplift. The researchers found that ground movement coincided with nearby sequences of wastewater injection rates and volume and CO2 injection in nearby wells.
Also related to the ground’s sinking and upheaval are dissolving salt formations due to freshwater leaking into abandoned underground oil facilities, as well as the extraction of oil.
Sinking and uplift detected from Wink to Fort Stockton
As might be expected, the most significant subsidence is about a half-mile east of the huge Wink No. 2 sinkhole, where there are two subsidence bowls, one of which has sunk more than 15.5 inches a year. The rapid sinking is most likely caused by water leaking through abandoned wells into the Salado formation and dissolving salt layers, threatening possible ground collapse.
At two wastewater injection wells 9.3 miles west of Wink and Kermit, the radar detected upheaval of about 2.1 inches that coincided with increases in injection volume. The injection wells extend about 4,921 feet to 5,577 feet deep into a sandstone formation.
In the vicinity of 11 CO2 injection wells nearly seven miles southwest of Monahans, the radar analysis detected surface uplift of more than 1 inch. The wells are about 2,460 feet to 2,657 feet deep. As with wastewater injection, CO2 injection increased pore pressure in the rocks, so when stress was relieved it was followed by uplift of about 1 inch at the surface.
The researchers also looked at an area 4.3 miles southwest of Imperial, where significant subsidence from fresh water flowing through cracked well casings, corroded steel pipes and unplugged abandoned wells has been widely reported.
Water there has leaked into the easily dissolved Salado formation, created voids, and caused the ground to sink and water to rise from the subsurface, including creating Boehmer Lake, which didn’t exist before 2003.
Radar analysis by the SMU team detected rapid subsidence ranging from three-fourths of an inch to nearly 4 inches around active wells, abandoned wells and orphaned wells.
“Movements around the roads and oil facilities to the southwest of Imperial, Texas, should be thoroughly monitored to mitigate potential catastrophes,” the researchers write in the study.
About 5.5 miles south of Pecos, their radar analysis detected more than 1 inch of subsidence near new wells drilled via hydraulic fracturing and in production since early 2015. There have also been six small earthquakes recorded there in recent years, suggesting the deformation of the ground generated accumulated stress and caused existing faults to slip.
“We have seen a surge of seismic activity around Pecos in the last five to six years. Before 2012, earthquakes had not been recorded there. At the same time, our results clearly indicate that ground deformation near Pecos is occurring,” Kim said. “Although earthquakes and surface subsidence could be coincidence, we cannot exclude the possibility that these earthquakes were induced by hydrocarbon production activities.”
Scientists: Boost the network of seismic stations to better detect activity
Kim stated the need for improved earthquake location and detection threshold through an expanded network of seismic stations, along with continuous surface monitoring with the demonstrated radar remote sensing methods.
“This is necessary to learn the cause of recent increased seismic activity,” Kim said. “Our efforts to continuously monitor West Texas with this advanced satellite technique can help sustain safe, ongoing oil production.”
Near real-time monitoring of ground deformation possible in a few years
The satellite radar datasets allowed the SMU geophysicists to detect both two-dimension east-west deformation of the ground, as well as vertical deformation.
Lu, a leading scientist in InSAR applications, is a member of the Science Team for the dedicated U.S. and Indian NASA-ISRO (called NISAR) InSAR mission, set for launch in 2021 to study hazards and global environmental change.
InSAR accesses a series of images captured by a read-out radar instrument mounted on the orbiting satellite Sentinel-1A/B. The satellites orbit 435 miles above the Earth’s surface. Sentinel-1A was launched in 2014 and Sentinel-1B in 2016 as part of the European Union’s Copernicus program.
The Sentinel-1A/B constellation bounces a radar signal off the earth, then records the signal as it bounces back, delivering measurements. The measurements allow geophysicists to determine the distance from the satellite to the ground, revealing how features on the Earth’s surface change over time.
“Near real-time monitoring of ground deformation at high spatial and temporal resolutions is possible in a few years, using multiple satellites such as Sentinel-1A/B, NISAR and others,” said Lu. “This will revolutionize our capability to characterize human-induced and natural hazards, and reduce their damage to humanity, infrastructure and the energy industry.”
Materials provided by Southern Methodist University. Journal Reference: Jin-Woo Kim, Zhong Lu. Association between localized geohazards in West Texas and human activities, recognized by Sentinel-1A/B satellite radar imagery. Scientific Reports, 2018; 8 (1) DOI: 10.1038/s41598-018-23143-6
On the subject of fracking, I commend the government of Nova Scotia when it states that all information possible must be considered.
Here are some facts to consider.
There is no question that someone might make money in extracting the trapped gasses in the rock formations underlying certain regions of our province. Nova Scotia is exceptional when it comes to its geological makeup and history. It was glaciated beginning approximately two million years ago and ending 9,000 years ago. When maximum thickness of glacial ice was on top of Nova Scotia (1.5 kilometres or one mile thick), the weight of the ice pushed the rock crust of the Earth down.
This displaced the hot, pliable mantle rocks beneath the crust to the side and outwards, where there was no weight from the overlying crustal rocks and glacial ice. This created a bulge in the displaced mantle material under the crust, which is referred to as the peripheral bulge. As stated in the scientific paper by Garry Quinlan and Christopher Beaumont of the Department of Oceanography, Dalhousie University, in 1981:
“As this ice melts the resulting isostatic disequilibrium causes this material to flow back from the bulge toward the rebounding ice centre. The large North American ice sheets did not melt instantaneously and the bulge produced by this ice migrated inward through Atlantic Canada following the retreating ice edge. This migration, involving mass redistribution in the highly viscous interior of the Earth, could not keep pace with the comparatively rapid glacial retreat and, therefore, continued to take place long after deglaciation was complete.”
When the glacial ice melted away, that peripheral bulge began to move back to the northwest. The bulge is presently beneath Hants, Cumberland and Colchester counties and parts of Cape Breton.
The bulge is causing our province to tilt. The Atlantic shore of Nova Scotia is descending at a rate of about 30 cm (one foot) per hundred years and the Fundy/Chignecto area is rising.
Physical evidence of the sinking land can be seen in Louisbourg. The mooring ring on the wharf now sits approximately 60 cm (two feet) below high tide. The Chignecto shoreline is rising, as evidenced by the raised beaches (beaches originally formed at sea level but are now higher than sea level) in several areas. This can be seen at Sand Cove in Cape Chignecto Provincial Park. It is the rising of the landforms (or isostatic readjustment) and associated upwards pressures that are of concern.
Springhill has tragically lost many miners to a phenomenon known as a “bump.” That is when the floor of the mine, weakened by the mining process, suddenly and catastrophically ruptures and crashes into the roof of the mine. A bump is felt above ground as a minor earthquake.
Injection of fracking fluids at depth may cause similar bumps by fracturing the rock and providing mechanisms for the rock to give way more easily. Although the quakes may be relatively minor and between 3 and 5 on the Richter scale, they will still be felt and may be quite unnerving.
Earthquakes have gone from no more than a dozen a year in Oklahoma to 888 per year today. This is widely attributed to fracking and the disposal of oil-drilling byproducts and other waste water injections into the rock formations.
The likelihood and potential risk of increased minor earthquakes in Nova Scotia must be taken into consideration.
In addition, it should be noted that the vertical shear strain rate is highest under Cumberland, Hants, Colchester counties and parts of Cape Breton — locations of the preferred sediments to be drilled for fracking. Some very serious research needs to be done, and unbiased information provided.
Fracking weakens the structural integrity of the rock into which the fracking fluids are injected. This weakening may create a situation similar to the underground mining in Springhill and its inherent weakening of the bedrock there.
If the people living in the areas deemed prime for fracking, as listed in the Onshore Petroleum Atlas recently released by the Nova Scotia Department of Energy, are content to have their homes shaken, animals agitated, and are OK with the possible risk to their groundwater, then fracking may be acceptable there.
If not, then perhaps the moratorium should be proclaimed and remain in effect indefinitely.
Robert G. Grantham is a retired geologist who lives in Stewiacke.
2015 12 01: “Abnormally dangerous and ultra hazardous activity.” Did TRC or Chevron’s fracing kill Robert David Taylor? What happened to California regulators’ vows to make steam injections safer? “Safer?” Why not make it “safe?”