First criminal case against a Shale firm opens for toxic frac waste spill/leak/dumping; XTO Energy Inc., subsidiary of Exxon Mobil Corp. hires three law firms to defend itself

First criminal case against a Shale firm opens by Andrew Maykuth, December 19, 2013, Inquirer
WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. – A former state environmental inspector indicated Wednesday that there was evidence of previous, unreported spills on a Marcellus Shale gas drilling site where he discovered toxic wastewater gushing onto the ground in 2010. Jeremy Daniel, 32, an inspector for the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection at the time, said he found puddles of wastewater, sand, and a “defined area of dead vegetation” flowing from several steel wastewater storage tanks on a Lycoming County well site operated by XTO Energy Inc. Daniel was called as a witness in a preliminary hearing on criminal charges that the state brought in September against XTO, Exxon Mobil Corp.’s shale-drilling subsidiary. The state says XTO spilled more than 50,000 gallons of toxic wastewater at its drilling site without reporting the leak as required.

The case, the first criminal action against a Marcellus Shale drilling company since the natural gas boom began five years ago, has taken on political and symbolic importance largely because of the players involved – Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane vs. the nation’s largest oil company. Both sides brought lots of legal and public relations firepower to the courtroom Wednesday. XTO has hired three legal firms to “vigorously” defend itself. The Attorney General’s Office was represented by some of its top lawyers from Harrisburg. The presence of two well-supported legal teams and a case involving complex environmental law was staggering for District Judge James G. Carn, a veteran magistrate who usually hears misdemeanors and traffic violations in his 18- by 35-foot courtroom. “This is whole new territory for me,” he told the lawyers. After hearing a full day’s testimony from six witnesses called by the Attorney General’s Office, Carn took the case under advisement. He must decide whether it can move ahead to a full trial in Lycoming County Court.

The charges involve a spill that Daniel discovered by chance during a routine, unannounced inspection on XTO’s Marquardt well site in Penn Township on Nov. 16, 2010. There is little dispute that wastewater produced by hydraulically fractured wells leaked from the site. How much leaked, and whether the leak was a criminal act, is at issue. … A key aspect of the case is that it remains a mystery who pulled the plug on the tank containing fracking water. “Who caused the spill?” asked Thomas J. Kelly Jr., a Washington lawyer on XTO’s team. “I don’t know, sir,” said Daniel, who left DEP in August to work for a natural gas pipeline company. The exchange prompted an objection from Glenn A. Parno, the attorney general’s top environmental prosecutor, who argued that the state does not have to blame an individual responsible, or even show nefarious intent. XTO, as the permit holder, is responsible for safe drilling operations on its site. XTO is charged with five counts of unlawful conduct under the Clean Streams Law and three counts under the Solid Waste Management Act. XTO portrays the spill as a minor event – it says closer to 6,300 gallons leaked – that resulted in no lasting environmental damage. [Emphasis added]

[Refer also to:

Pa. well site will be focus of fierce legal battle; Criminal charges for toxic frac waste spill/leak/dumping stun drilling industry

Dangerous levels of radioactivity found at fracking waste site in Pennsylvania, Hundreds of disposal sites for frac wastewater could be similarly affected

Investors sue BP’s ex-CEO Tony Hayward and Doug Suttles, now Encana CEO; Encana chops executives, five senior managers gone including USA President Jeff Wojahn, who headed the unit when it was accused of collusion

Attorney general files criminal charges against Marcellus gas drilling company for apparent intentional waste dumping

Oilfield company fined $1.5 million for disposal violation

Halliburton, Baker Hughes receive antitrust inquiries from Department of Justice about fracking business, Schlumberger possibly also being investigated

Chesapeake Energy subject to U.S. antitrust investigation for possible collusion with Encana, Company subpoenaed to produce documents for grand jury in Michigan land sales probe

New Encana head Doug Suttles [past senior BP executive who reportedly lied about the Gulf of Mexico Deepwater Horizon disaster] plays cards close to chest

Fracking company Encana suspected of contaminating ground water at Pavillion Wyoming, takes control of investigation, EPA refuses to finalize study blaming fracking for water pollution

Are Fracking Wastewater Wells Poisoning the Ground beneath Our Feet? Leaking injection wells may pose a risk–and the science has not kept pace with the growing glut of wastewater

Battered Encana taps former BP exec Doug Suttles, who reportedly covered-up the extent of the Deepwater Horizon disaster, as new CEO

SNC-Lavalin to replace chairman Gwyn Morgan, directors in board revamp, Bribery probe of SCN-Lavalin reaches former spy watchdog

Energy lobbyist, Ex Encana VP Gerard Protti, appointed as Alberta’s new top energy regulator

In Alberta And B.C.: Stephen Harper Destroying The Rule Of Law

B.C. Oil and Gas Commission lacks ‘transparency’ on fracking violations

Ohio EPA official: Lupo dumped drilling waste at least six times

Ohio revokes permits of two firms tied to illegal Youngstown dumping

Government cracks down on Canadian companies bribing foreign officials, what about bribery and corruption within Canada?

SNC-Lavalin (Gwyn Morgan is Chairman SNC Lavalin and Director of Encana) paid $160-million in Libyan bribes, RCMP says; SNC-Lavalin hires former Watergate investigator to advise on anti-corruption

SNC-Lavalin will face criminal charges, analyst says, but buy it anyway

Swiss Probe $139M SNC-Lavalin Laundering Case, Gwyn Morgan SNC-Lavalin Chair says company aiming at improving compliance, but won’t comment on allegation $22.5M payment linked to MUHC superhospital project

Beaumont co. Pemco Services Inc. fined $1.5 million for illegal dumping

Alberta mother of three boys, Kimberly Mildenstein of Eagle Hill Alberta Spared Criminal Record for Uttering Threats after Numerous Concerns to the Energy Resources Conservation Board Were Ignored

A Dead Man’s Prints, RCMP request to fingerprint Wiebo Ludwig’s corpse refused

$250,000 in community donation projects following Encana deadly sour gas leak

Toxic Wastewater Dumped in Streets and Rivers at Night: Gas Profiteers Getting Away With Shocking Environmental Crimes, Allan Shipman was found guilty of illegally dumping millions of gallons of natural gas drilling wastewater. But he’s part of a much bigger problem

Alberta university professor Lois Frank has charges stayed for protesting hydraulic fracturing

Crown decides not to prosecute professor and grandmother Lois Frank for protesting fracking

EnCana Corporation facing criminal charges for Failure of Piping at EnCana Sour Gas Wellsite A5-7-77-14 L W6M ]

This entry was posted in Global Frac News, Other Lawsuits. Bookmark the permalink.