2019 02 13 Print copy in The Globe and Mail:
Alberta Auditor-General probing links between energy regulator and consultancy firm by Jeff Lewis, February 12, 2019, The Globe and Mail
Alberta’s Auditor-General and Public Interest Commissioner are probing ties between the province’s energy regulator and an international not-for-profit set up by its former president and CEO almost two years before his abrupt resignation late last year.
Auditor-General Doug Wylie is examining “any and all aspects” of the relationship between the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER) and an organization called the International Centre of Regulatory Excellence (ICORE), a spokesperson for Mr. Wylie’s office confirmed.
The audit follows a complaint from a whistle-blower last year that launched a separate probe by Public Interest Commissioner Marianne Ryan, according to internal AER e-mails obtained by The Globe and Mail. Her office would not comment, citing internal policy, but under provincial legislation she can investigate allegations of gross mismanagement of public funds, a public asset or the delivery of a public service.
The investigations raise potentially thorny questions for the NDP government about oversight at the AER just ahead of a spring election in which the party faces a tough challenge from the United Conservative Party under Jason Kenney.
Premier Rachel Notley’s government has touted efforts by the AER to accelerate approvals of major oil sands projects – even as the province struggles to clean up thousands of orphaned oil and gas wells.
ICORE launched with great fanfare in February, 2017, with plans to advise other countries on regulation, starting with Mexico’s newly liberalized energy sector.
But current and former AER employees described to The Globe an opaque entity whose top executives, including then-president and chief executive Jim Ellis, allegedly diverted technical resources and staff from the regulator’s daily business.
The employees were granted anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to media.
Mr. Ellis is listed as the sole director for a company created in March, 2017, called ICORE Energy Services Ltd. A federal not-for-profit with the same name was registered that June with Mr. Ellis listed as a director.
At the time, the AER described itself as a founding member of the not-for-profit and said it would provide in-kind services under what it called a “strategic partnership.”
Mr. Ellis could not be reached by phone for comment. He did not respond to a LinkedIn message, and no one answered the door at a Calgary address listed on registry documents. A lawyer named in filings for the not-for-profit declined to comment when reached by phone.
Martin Krezalek, a senior adviser at the AER and previously ICORE’s chief of operations and administration, referred questions about ICORE to the AER’s media department.
Last year, the CBC reported that Mr. Ellis now lives in Penticton, B.C. He was listed as ICORE’s president in a June, 2017, news release.
The former military commander and deputy minister led the AER for five years, but resigned last fall after the release of records showing it could cost almost four times what the regulator had disclosed to clean up oil and gas operations in the province.
The AER said on Nov. 2 that his retirement had been planned for several months and that it took effect on Jan. 31. On Nov. 6, a top executive told staff in an e-mail that an investigation into the not-for-profit was under way.
“In the interim the Public Interest Commissioner is requiring that I inform staff working on ICORE related projects not to delete or destroy any records, personal or otherwise, relating to ICORE Energy Services Ltd., or ICORE Energy Services (NFP),” Charlene Graham, the executive vice-president of law and general counsel, wrote in the e-mail, a copy of which was obtained by The Globe.
A follow-up e-mail on Nov. 9 from Ms. Graham told staff to continue work on the “ICORE Development Project,” and stressed that the investigation did not mean there had been “any findings of wrongdoing.”
It is unclear whether that project received direct funding or what it entails; there is no mention of it in the regulator’s most recent budget, which is set by the provincial government and funded by the oil and gas industry through administrative levies.
The AER would not answer detailed questions, including whether its lawyers had ever expressed concerns that ICORE conflicted with the regulator’s mandate or if the AER board was fully apprised of its work.
AER spokeswoman Cara Tobin said ICORE is a separate legal entity that was registered under federal law and that the provincial regulator severed the relationship in December, although she would not say why.
“Matters relating to ICORE are currently under review by the Public Interest Commissioner. The AER is fully co-operating with this review, however, this means we cannot respond to your questions at this time,” she said in an e-mailed statement.
In a statement, Energy Minister Margaret McCuaig-Boyd’s office said the minister first became aware of the probe last November. “Due to ongoing concerns, the Energy Minister and Environment and Parks Minister requested the AER suspend all ICORE-related activities that same month,” spokesman Mike McKinnon said. He would not say what those concerns were or how the government might address them.
Publicly, the AER said ICORE would help train regulators in other countries. The Southern Alberta Institute of Technology (SAIT) was tapped to develop coursework. But SAIT spokesman Chris Gerritsen said the curriculum was never delivered.
“Our activity with ICORE did not go past the early stage development as we did not have an agreement in place,” he said in an e-mailed statement.
Refer also to:
2009 02 21: Cupid’s arrow pierces energy regulator, Alberta’s ERCB [Previously EUB and ERCB before that, now AER]
…
Just when I started to think I’d entered a Seinfeld script, things got more entertaining. I called up Andrew Nikiforuk, the one person I know who is familiar with the board and, married with three sons, also with the ways of love. But whereas I was thinking possible candlelight dinners and walks in the park, Nikiforuk’s mind went straight to the gutter.“People have been saying for years that the ERCB [now AER] and the industry are in bed together,” says Nikiforuk, an award-winning author who has followed the industry for years. “Now we have hard evidence to prove it.” No fan of the board, Nikiforuk says this latest boondoggle is another example of the hazards of having a provincial energy regulator that receives 58 per cent [now 100 per cent!] of its funding from the oil and gas industry. “Their mandate to be impartial has been compromised once again, but this time it’s in the bedroom, not the boardroom.” Nikiforuk is nevertheless impressed the staid environs of a hearing would spawn a relationship with enough sparks to shut down the whole show. “Sex is the last thing you’d think of when you walk into an ERCB hearing,” he says. “I would actually argue that it’s an effective form of birth control.”
2017 07 08: AER ramping up the propaganda, ready to expand global impact